Saturday, June 20, 2026

After Ten years


 

This is St. Andrew’s Church in the picturesque village of Charmouth on the south coast of England. Just around the road is Abbots House, which was formerly the Queen’s Armes Hotel, where in September 1651 the on-the-run Charles II stayed while being chased by Oliver Cromwell’s Parliamentarian troops. Charles’ father, Charles I only two years earlier had lost his head for believing that a King’s authority was God given, therefore weakening parliament’s authority. Charles II must have been a slow learner because he had similar ideas, which caused the second civil war and why Cromwell was after him. In the event, Charles II escaped to France and Cromwell became became Lord Protector...King in everything but name. Cromwell died in 1658 and the later chaos created by his son, prompted parliament to call Charles II back and he ruled Britain successfully for 25 years.


Curious as I find all of that, I wandered around the cemetery of St. Andrew’s and saw a headstone, more like a box-tomb, of a man who had died in a duel, and another of a woman who had died of a broken heart. For close to ten years I have wondered at what the connection might have been, and after some digging, at last have come up with a plausable explanation.


James Warden was a respected ex-navy man, a Lieutenant in the Royal Navy, who had suffered the loss of his first wife and had brought up three young children on his own. On retirement, he went to Charmouth to retire, met his second wife and through an inheritance from an Aunt, he became Lord of Langmoor Manor (owner not peerage). Some say he liked to throw his weight around, and as the captain of ship no double he was used having orders obeyed and perhaps he was argumentative, even cantankerous with it. Reason enough for in April 1792, he became entangled in what turned out to be a vicious dispute with his neighbor, a fellow by the name of Bond, who was a neighboring landowner. Basically the dispute was over Bond’s dog wandering on Warden’s property, so a terse letter was sent and when the pair happened to meet on the road, the argument occurred.


The argument escalated and Warden lost his temper insulting Bond in the process, and as a point of honor, Bond challenged him to a duel. So on 22 April 1792, the pair met with pistols a the Hunters Lodge Inn, where Bond offered to forget the matter if Warden apologised... Warden refused. So the duel happened at what is known today as Challenge or Dead Man’s Field. It was over quickly when Warden shot first as per tradition, missed but putting a hole through Bond’s hat; Bond’s shot found Warden’s heart. Bond walked over to Warden’s body and said to his supports, ‘I believe he is dead, gentlemen.’ And he fled the country to Barbados to escape a likely murder charge... and returned some years after.


Warden’s widow, Elizabeth has this on her headstone, ‘After lingering upwards of six years … wasting with pinning sickness.’ Anyway, she inherited the Langmoor property, but moved to Axminster, just inside the next county boundary, where she led a respectable life, probably away from the gossip of Charmouth; so it seems whoever penned the message, did so with some poetic licence...because I found another little piece to add to the puzzle.


‘His wife, Elizabeth, was to survive by seven years, but not, it would seem as broken hearted, for a letter turned up where the writer says that Mrs. Warden welcomed, even courted her widowhood. It was she who sourced and chose the pistols, and later thanked the gentleman who had lent them; she made no effort to prevent the duel, even though she lived close to a magistrate who would have stopped it. In short, she seemed determined that one of them should fall. If Mr. Bond, her husband must be hanged, and if the latter, she was fairly rid of him.’ Dueling was illegal at the time.


Elizabeth was to lease Langmoor to a Mr. Dickens, and move to Axminster where she was to spend her last years. We don’t know for sure, but if James Warden was as bad tempered and unreasonable as it appears, maybe she did want rid of him... nevertheless she provided well for her step children. Oh, and her brother was a local vicar... who probably wrote the epitaph. All nice and clean.